We tend to prefer “down to earth” or “plain” speech here in the US, rather than anything that sounds privileged, haughty, artificial — or “foreign.” That is why we now have a President who cannot pronounce the word “nuclear.” Children who speak like Frasier and Niles will tend to be dealt with by their peers as the Kriezel (sp?) kids dealt with F. and N.
I also think that one or two fantastic phenomena inevitably engender millions of crappy imitators. In the fifties, Marlon Brando and James Dean opened the floodgates with their naturalistic approach, and
diction, voice quality and production started mattering even less in the movies than they did before. Hey, they’re getting miked, anyway.
A lot of African American actors are notable for exceptionally beautiful speech– I was just reminded of that because I happened to switch on PBS, where Joe Morton is narrating a documentary.
Posted by Juwanna Kumiko